Buy the Always Pan if you are buying one pan — $135 brings a lid, a spatula and a steamer basket that Caraway’s $125 does not — and buy Caraway’s fry pan if you finish dishes in a hot oven, where its 550°F rating beats the Always Pan’s 450°F. They photograph almost identically and sit ten dollars apart; on paper they are not the same pan, and the differences run in both directions.
We earn a commission if you buy through the links on this page. It has not changed a figure.
The Always Pan came in eight colourways on 16 October 2026, all $135; four are shown. Caraway’s fry pan came in eight colours on 26 October 2026, six at $125 and White and Black at $135. Images: Our Place.
Both prices come from each store’s structured product data and both change without notice. Our Place’s price log is on Our Place prices.
Sources: fromourplace.com product pages and product data (Always Pan 16 October 2026; Titanium Always Pan Pro 16 October, diameter 20 October) and carawayhome.com product page and product data, 26 October 2026. Caraway’s body and handle materials and its capacity are from the page as read on 25 August 2026; the page read on 26 October no longer states them. Figures a brand declines to publish are marked, not estimated. The third column is Our Place’s own answer to the oven question; its review is Titanium Always Pan Pro.
Our Place wins the box, and it is not close. Ten dollars more buys a modular steam-release lid, a nesting beechwood spatula and a steamer basket that doubles as a colander; Caraway’s $125 buys a pan, and its page says so: “Lid is not included”. Bought separately those are not ten-dollar items. On the single-pan purchase, Our Place is the better value.
Caraway wins the oven. “Oven Safe Up to 550°F” against Our Place’s 450°F — a hundred degrees of headroom that matters if you finish dishes under a broiler. Neither page mentions the broiler by name; every Our Place rating is on are Our Place pans oven safe.
Neither one is the safer pan. This is where most comparisons go wrong, so it is worth being blunt. Both brands publish an exclusion list: Our Place’s page says “made without PFAS” and then lists PFAS, PTFE, PFOA, lead and cadmium as absent; Caraway’s body copy says “thoughtfully crafted without PTFE, PFOA, and PFAS”, and an image caption adds lead and cadmium (read 26 October 2026). Both use a ceramic coating over an aluminium body. There is no meaningful safety gap between them, and if a review tells you one of these is toxic and the other is clean, it is selling you something. The words are explained on non-toxic cookware.
The warranty is three to one. Our Place’s three-year limited warranty against Caraway’s “1-Year Limited Warranty”. Our Place’s terms are on warranty and returns.
That inverts on sets. Caraway’s multi-piece sets have historically undercut Our Place’s, and they ship with storage. If you are furnishing a kitchen rather than buying one pan, price both configurations before you decide — the single-pan logic does not carry. Our Place’s sets are on cookware sets.
We have not cooked on both of these side by side. This is a specification and value comparison, and it is honest about being one. What it cannot answer is the question that decides most of these purchases: which coating is still releasing eggs cleanly in eighteen months. Nobody publishes that reliably, including us. Owner reports on both brands describe performance falling off somewhere between year one and year two, which is normal for ceramic nonstick of any make. Treat any review claiming a definitive long-term winner without a documented long-term test with suspicion.
The genuine caveat applies equally to both: ceramic coatings degrade with heat and abrasion, and a scratched, overheated pan of either brand is worse than a well-kept one of the other.
Caraway’s page, read 26 October 2026: no capacity (the page gave 2.7 qt on 25 August), no body or handle material, no box list, and the answer to its own FAQ “Can I put my pans in the dishwasher?” did not load. Our Place’s Always Pan page: induction only in the page metadata, and no broiler statement.
The one-pan buyer. The lid, spatula and steamer basket are worth considerably more than the ten-dollar difference, and the three-year warranty is three times Caraway’s one.
You finish dishes in a hot oven or under a broiler, where a hundred degrees of headroom is a real constraint rather than a spec-sheet detail; or Caraway’s colours are the ones you want — eight on 26 October 2026, against the Always Pan’s eight. And price the sets separately from the pans: the single-pan verdict does not transfer to a four-piece purchase, and pretending it does would cost you money.
If oven heat is the issue, Our Place’s own answer is the Titanium Always Pan Pro: 1000°F, dishwasher safe, limited lifetime warranty, $179 in Chrome or Brushed and $199 in Gold on 16 October 2026. With HexClad in the picture: Our Place vs Caraway vs HexClad.
Our Place’s 10.5-inch Always Pan with the price on our last read and the date. Every size is on the Always Pan hub.

Both publish exclusion lists. Our Place’s page says “made without PFAS” and then lists PFAS, PTFE, PFOA, lead and cadmium as absent. Caraway’s body copy says “thoughtfully crafted without PTFE, PFOA, and PFAS”, and an image caption adds lead and cadmium (read 26 October 2026). Neither has a safety advantage over the other on published evidence.
Neither, on the pages as we read them on 25 August 2026: both brands specified hand washing only, and Caraway stated directly that the dishwasher will damage the ceramic coating. On 26 October Caraway’s FAQ answer did not load for us, so that line could not be re-verified; Our Place still says hand wash only. Care for the Always Pan is on how to clean the Always Pan.
Both. Caraway’s page says “All-Stovetop Compatible” and, in an image caption, “compatible with gas, electric, and induction cooktops”. Our Place states compatibility with all cooktops including induction — though on its Cookware Duo page rather than the standalone Always Pan listing, which is why this question keeps getting asked.
Our Place publishes 3.9 lb with the lid. Caraway publishes 2.7 lb for the 10.5-inch fry pan on 26 October 2026; it gave no weight when we read the page on 25 August. Caraway’s figure is for the pan alone, since no lid is included, so the two are not like for like.
Our Place includes its modular steam-release lid at the $135 base price. Caraway’s $125 fry pan is the pan alone — “Lid is not included” — and the glass lid is an add-on priced separately.
Forty-five dollars under Caraway on promotion, and it is not the close call the price suggests: GreenPan vs Caraway. All three side by side, where the cheapest pan wins most of the rows: Our Place vs Caraway vs GreenPan. One year against a lifetime, and the care instructions tell the story: Caraway vs HexClad. Every comparison on this site is on the index.
Our Place’s figures come from its product page and product data, read 16 October 2026. Caraway’s come from its product page and product data, first read 25 August and re-read 26 October 2026; where the October page no longer shows a figure, the August read is given with its date, and figures either brand declines to publish are marked rather than estimated. Neither brand supplied product, saw this page or approved it, and this is a comparison of published specifications and value, not a hands-on test. How we check these pages.
Our Place prices and specifications last verified 16–26 October 2026; competitor prices re-read 26–28 October 2026 (All-Clad 25 August).
How we check these pages