GreenPan's Valencia Pro undercuts Caraway by $45, runs 50°F hotter, weighs less, goes in the dishwasher and is warranted for life against Caraway's one year. Caraway's answer is the sentence it writes about PFAS.
Forty-five dollars cheaper, 50°F hotter, over a pound lighter, dishwasher safe, and warranted for life. Nineteen years of Thermolon iteration behind it.
Names PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead and cadmium as excluded. GreenPan says “without intentionally added PFAS” — standard language, but a hedged one.
Buy the GreenPan Valencia Pro unless you have a specific reason not to. It is cheaper, lighter, hotter-rated, dishwasher tolerant and warranted for life. On every measurable axis except capacity and width it is the better pan for less money.
Buy Caraway if the flat exclusion list is what you want in writing, or if the colourway is genuinely part of the purchase. Both are honest reasons. Neither is a performance argument, and it is worth being clear-eyed that you are paying $45 for wording and appearance.
If you were going to spend Caraway money anyway, it is worth looking at what else $125 buys in this category before committing.
Both publish PFAS-free claims. Caraway's is broader in writing, naming PTFE, PFOA, lead and cadmium alongside PFAS. GreenPan's product page says “without intentionally added PFAS” and does not carry the other exclusions. That is a difference in drafting, not demonstrated evidence of any difference in the pans.
GreenPan states dishwasher safe with hand washing recommended. Caraway states the dishwasher will damage the coating. Hand washing extends the life of either.
GreenPan, decisively — a limited lifetime warranty on manufacturer defects against Caraway's one year.
GreenPan, at 600°F against 550°F. Both ratings are ceilings rather than recommendations — ceramic nonstick of any brand degrades faster the hotter it is run.
Ten dollars more than Caraway and it includes a lid, a beechwood spatula and a steamer basket, with the same flat exclusion list and three times the warranty.
Price checked 25 August 2026.
GreenPan for value and specifications. Caraway for the exclusion list and the colourways. Both defensible for different buyers.
See GreenPanSee CarawayPrices checked 25 August 2026 and change without notice.
We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. This page recommends GreenPan — the cheapest pan of the three named on it — for most buyers.
This is a comparison of published specifications, not a hands-on test. Product photography belongs to GreenPan and Caraway respectively. Figures verified 25 August 2026 against each store's own product data.
1919 Cookware is an independent comparison site. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you, and it does not decide our verdicts — we name a competitor as the better buy on more than half of these pages. Every comparison is built from published manufacturer specifications, verified against each store's own product data where such data exists, and each page states plainly what it could not establish. We do not accept press samples and no brand reviews our pages before publication. Figures last verified 25 August 2026.
GreenPan launched Thermolon in 2007 and effectively invented ceramic nonstick as a consumer category. Caraway arrived in 2019, made it beautiful, and took the market. Line the spec sheets up and the older company is ahead on almost everything that can be measured — for forty-five dollars less.
Sources: greenpan.us and carawayhome.com product pages plus Caraway's warranty page, retrieved 25 August 2026. Both prices were confirmed against each store's own structured product data. The GreenPan figure is for the 10in Valencia Pro frypan without a lid; both pans here are pan-only configurations. GreenPan's $79.99 is a special price against a $114.99 list.
Caraway states its pans are made without PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, lead and cadmium. A flat list, no qualifiers. GreenPan's product page says its nonstick is made without intentionally added PFAS, and carries no PFOA, lead or cadmium claim on that page at all.
“Intentionally added” is careful, defensible industry language. It acknowledges that trace presence in a supply chain cannot be guaranteed against, and a company writing it may simply be the more scrupulous drafter. It is not evidence of anything. But if the reason you are in this category is that you want the strongest available assurance in writing, Caraway hands you the flatter sentence, and that is worth forty-five dollars to some buyers.
GreenPan is $45 cheaper, more than a pound lighter, rated 50°F hotter, dishwasher tolerant where Caraway forbids it outright, and warranted for life where Caraway warrants twelve months. It also publishes a hard-anodised body and a named induction base, both of which are more specific engineering disclosures than Caraway offers.
Caraway publishes capacity where GreenPan does not, is half an inch wider, and comes in eight colourways against GreenPan's more utilitarian range. If the pan lives on your hob rather than in a drawer, that is a real consideration — it is just not a performance one.
GreenPan has been refining Thermolon since 2007 and Caraway's coating is proprietary and undescribed. It is reasonable to think the older formulation is more mature. It is not demonstrated — neither company publishes comparative durability data, and no independent long-term test of both exists. Owner reports on both describe performance falling off in year two, which is what ceramic nonstick does.